In partnership with
Ever find yourself staring at your email list, wondering why so many subscribers have gone silent, not opening or interacting with your messages? You’re not alone.
Re-engaging a cold audience can feel daunting, but it’s one of the most rewarding strategies in email marketing.
Let’s dive into how to bring those subscribers back to life.
Sponsored by PodPitch
Save 13 Hours Weekly of Podcast Pitching with PodPitch.com
It's 2025. Want to finally be a regular podcast guest in your industry? PodPitch will make it happen. Even the beehiiv team uses it!
The best way to advertise isn't Meta or Google – it's appearing on dozens of podcasts that your customers already love.
You could write a few emails yourself to podcast hosts...
Or you could automate thousands of emails going out weekly, pitching your people as the PERFECT next podcast guest.
With PodPitch.com...
Log in with your email
Load your brand info
Click "automate"
Emails pitching your team as the perfect next guest will start sending out automatically to podcast hosts.
Big brands like Feastables are already using it instead of expensive PR Agencies.
Six steps for re-engaging your audience
Step 1: Identify Your Cold Subscribers
Not everyone who hasn’t opened an email is a lost cause. Start by defining what “cold” means for your audience. For some, it might be no engagement in 30 days; for others, it could be 90 days. Use your email platform to segment this group—you’ll want to target them specifically.
Step 2: Segment with Purpose
Now that you know who your cold subscribers are think about what might rekindle their interest. Did they sign up for a specific resource? Have they clicked on certain types of content in the past? Use this data to create segments within your unengaged audience and craft messages that speak directly to their interests.
Step 3: Personalize Like a Pro
Personalization isn’t just using someone’s name in the subject line (though that helps!). Dive deeper—reference why they subscribed, their past behaviors, or topics they’ve engaged with. For example:
“We Miss You, [First Name]!”
“Still Interested in [Topic]?”
“Here’s What’s New with [Product They Wanted]”
The more relevant your message, the better your chance of winning them back.
Step 4: Offer Something Irresistible
Sometimes, all it takes is the right nudge to re-engage a subscriber. Think exclusive discounts, a free resource, or a sneak peek at new content. Make them feel like coming back will be worth their time.
Examples:
“A Special Gift for Our Favorite Subscribers”
“We’ve Been Saving This Just for You”
“[First Name], Claim Your Free Guide Today!”
Step 5: Re-Engagement Campaigns
Design 2–3 emails to reconnect with your cold audience. Start with a friendly “we miss you” email, follow up with an irresistible offer, and close with a “last chance” message to create urgency. Don’t be afraid to use bold subject lines like:
“Do You Still Want to Hear From Us?”
“Last Chance to Stay on Our List!”
“We’re Cleaning House—Want to Stay?”
Step 6: Know When to Let Go
If your re-engagement efforts don’t work, letting those subscribers go is okay. Keeping inactive subscribers on your list can hurt your deliverability. Send a final email asking if they’d like to stay, and remove those who don’t respond. A smaller, engaged list is better than a big, silent one.
Final Thoughts
Re-engaging a cold audience isn’t just about getting them to open an email—it’s about reminding them why they joined your list in the first place. Be human, be relevant, and don’t be afraid to experiment. You can turn those silent subscribers into active, engaged fans with the right approach.
Thanks for reading. See you next week.
If you want to start your own beehive newsletter, use this referral link. You'll get a 30-day trial + 20% OFF for 3 months, and I'll be rewarded for referring you.
Connect with me here
bio.link/mikeholden
x.com/mikeholden
linkedin.com/in/mikeholdenmarketing
Sponsored by AdQuick
Modernize your marketing with AdQuick
AdQuick unlocks the benefits of Out Of Home (OOH) advertising in a way no one else has. Approaching the problem with eyes to performance, created for marketers with the engineering excellence you’ve come to expect for the internet.
Marketers agree OOH is one of the best ways for building brand awareness, reaching new customers, and reinforcing your brand message. It’s just been difficult to scale. But with AdQuick, you can easily plan, deploy and measure campaigns just as easily as digital ads, making them a no-brainer to add to your team’s toolbox.